The Backstreet Boy performs a duet along with his son after Baylee Littrell impresses with an authentic music as Underwood earns the nickname “Jukebox Carrie” for the surprising depth of her lyrical data — together with Korn and Drowning Pool.
American Idol continues to lean into nepo infants as the following era of superstars appears for his or her huge break. Within the newest case, mentioned famous person was Backstreet Boys member Brian Littrell, whose son Baylee was trying to make his personal mark.
In fact, that meant additionally trotting Brian out to carry out a duet along with his proficient son, however not after Baylee had his huge solo second to attempt to impress the judging panel, together with newcomer to the panel — however to not Idol — Carrie Underwood.
After courting controversy at Donald Trump’s second inauguration by performing “America the Stunning” — nicely, mainly by being there — Carrie and ABC had been positively hoping her followers had been able to forgive and overlook as she joins Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan on the panel.
Getty
Carrie Underwood Acting at Trump Inauguration Leaves Social Media Divided
View Story
Carrie, after all, received her begin on the then-Fox present when she received its fourth season, happening to arguably change into the largest star the present has ever discovered with regards to album gross sales. As of late, followers debate that problem between Carrie and Season 1 winner Kelly Clarkson.
Kelly proved her chops on a lot of these reveals for years when she served as a Coach on NBC’s rival singing present The Voice, whereas she’s additionally made a number of returns to Idol herself. However this marks the primary time a former winner has returned as a choose on the present that made them.
Carrie definitely felt snug within the room proper from the soar — or a minimum of the intelligent modifying made it really feel that method — as she was simple and comfy with the entire contestants, whereas displaying off her personal musical variety as a fan.
Tonight we realized @carrieunderwood virtually is aware of each lyric to each music, and is called “Jukebox Carrie”… However how about “Carrie-oke-Machine”? #americanidol
— Ryan Seacrest (@RyanSeacrest) March 10, 2025
@RyanSeacrest
Whereas her profession was in nation music, she rapidly acknowledged Baylee Littrell’s household resemblance to his well-known father. “There’s one thing about you that appears acquainted,” she quipped when he got here within the room.
Idol then confirmed each Baylee’s upbringing within the shadow of BSB, in addition to Underwood having the boy band’s posters on her wall. “You need to forgive me, I didn’t have your dad’s posters in my room,” Luke teased his fellow choose.
“Following in my dad’s footsteps is frightening as a result of his profession to me is likely one of the most extraordinary in music historical past. Nobody can ever examine,” mentioned Baylee of his father’s profession. He mentioned that whereas he could have inherited his pop’s vocals, he positively did not get his dance abilities.

Instagram/Getty
Kelly Stafford Defends Carrie Underwood Acting at Trump’s Inauguration
View Story
As for the nepo of all of it, Brian argued, “Clearly, rising up within the business, lots of people have a look at that as such a perk. Nevertheless it’s not simple. I’ve all the time informed everyone that he’s 10 instances extra proficient than I ever was.”
Quite than lean on his father’s musical pedigree, or some other artist, Baylee opted to showcase his personal artistry with an authentic music, “Ready on Myself to Die,” which he mentioned “is about me personally wanting to surrender and never giving up but.”
“Belief me, I want I wished to do one thing fully totally different,” he informed the cameras, referring to his well-known pedigree. “But when I’m not doing music, there’s no method I can actually exist.”
After showcasing his expertise on the music, Luke invited Brian to affix him in singing the refrain of his authentic music, giving the panel a duet second. By then, although, Carrie was already mesmerized by his vocals.

Chris Daughtry Unveils Blackout Tattoos And Explains Why He Did It
View Story
Not gonna lie, I noticed the title on the sheet and when he walked in thought he regarded awfully acquainted. 🤔 Greater than something, I wished Baylee to know he had his personal expertise to face on…such a pure and mild voice. @AmericanIdol #AmericanIdol
— Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood) March 10, 2025
@carrieunderwood
“I feel you possibly can go very, very far on this competitors,” she informed him, including, “To your famous person singer dad to return in right here, I really feel like for anyone else, it might make you look dangerous. Nevertheless it didn’t. You had been proper there with him. You didn’t pale, you didn’t shrink back. You had been like, ‘That is my second.'”
American Idol continues to lean into nepo infants, as they definitely assist assure press protection for the growing older collection. Final yr, it was Loretta Lynn’s granddaughter Emmy Russell, who just lately expressed frustration on the music pushing her to carry out one in every of her grandmother’s songs.
She made it into the Prime 5, whereas Pink Sizzling Chili Pepper’s drummer Chad Smith’s daughter Ava Maybee and Honeymoon Suite guitarist Derry Grehan’s daugher Leah Marlene each made Prime 10 in Season 20, alongside Aretha Franklin’s daughter Grace.

NBC
Woman Gaga SNL Sketches Ranked: Mike Myers, Rom-Coms, Slaying Slay, Birthday Hell & Extra Oddities
View Story
Season 21 welcomed Eurythmics’ Dave Stewart and his daughter Kaya Stewart, in addition to Glenn Mederios’ daughter Lyric. Different previous nepo infants have included Jim Carrey’s daughter Jane getting a Season 11 Golden Ticket, Doobie Brothers singer Tom Johnston’s daughter Lara Johnston, Brenda Ok. Starr’s daughter Gianna Isabella, and Jo Dee Messina’s cousin Alex Preston.
Exterior of music, former Trump advisor Kellyanne Conway’s daughter Claudia famously auditioned in 2021, whereas the daughter of NFL star Phillipp Sparks had a reasonably good run in Season 6 — as Jordin Sparks received all of it.
In the meantime, St. Louis Cardinals’ legend Ozzie Smith’s son Nikko Smith had a good run of his personal when he competed in opposition to Carrie again in Season 4.
On Sunday, Carrie proved why she was so successful each on the present and after successful it, showcasing the range in her musical influences and pursuits, even past boy band posters on her partitions.
She did get to get pleasure from some nation classics, in addition to getting emotional with one contestant who took on her personal observe, “Jesus Take the Wheel.” Fortunately for Breanna Nix, that gamble went nicely and paid off, securing her spot within the subsequent spherical. “You probably did a fantastic job with that,” Carrie informed her.
Probably the most stunning second for her fellow judges — which must also serve to ease considerations that her and Luke may see the present lean much more into the nation music style — got here when Carrie let the our bodies hit the ground.

Peacock/Instagram
Dylan Efron Confirms Relationship Standing and Teases If Marriage Is Within the Playing cards
View Story
“Who are you?” requested Lionel as Carrie Underwood completely received into one auditioner’s tackle Korn’s “Freak on a Leash.” Not solely did she know each single phrase, however she was singing together with the contestant named Insite.
Carrie even took it a step additional, becoming a member of him in entrance of her fellow judges to assist him with a hyped duet of Drowning Swimming pools’ “Our bodies.” Properly, Carrie helped with the counting, however it was clear she was a fan of the music, protecting the vitality up and serving to Insite safe a uncommon rock Golden Ticket.
The largest second for the judges, although, was the very first audition we received to see. Kolbi Jordan wowed them together with her tackle Chrisette Michele’s “Epiphany (I am Leaving),” rapidly incomes a spot within the subsequent spherical … however the judges weren’t completed together with her simply but.
After studying how a lot Chrisette idolizes Patti Labelle, Lionel dropped her title on the ground, after which received the business icon on the road. However even that wasn’t all of the judges had in thoughts for Chrisette.
The judges then booked her to carry out in entrance of 70,000 followers on the Tenessee Titans/New England Patriots soccer sport. Nevertheless it was additionally a ploy to get the singer in entrance of that vast crowd so they might hand out the season’s first Platinum Ticket improve, sending her straight via the primary spherical of Hollywood Week.

Getty
Scheana Shay Recollects Seeing Jax Taylor’s Cocaine Use on VPR: ‘Everybody Knew’
View Story
From competing with one contestant on trivia that concerned her personal Season 4 American Idol expertise — she forgot her second runner-up, however in any other case did very nicely — to displaying her musical vary and general optimism, Carrie was positively far much less on the market and bizarre than the lady she changed, Katy Perry.
She additionally did not flirt with any of the contestants, which turned a staple of Katy’s run. In truth, when one contestant shot his shot, Carrie shot again, “I am sufficiently old to be your momma!” That by no means stopped Katy!
Followers had been loving the vitality she introduced, lighting up social media with appreciation for the depth of her musical data, her expertise doing precisely what these contestants are doing, and seeing one of many best to ever do it assist usher within the subsequent era.
Whereas there was nonetheless some on-line grumbling about Carrie’s inauguration look, it appeared most of these folks had been simply expressing their refusal to observe, so that they did not actually weigh in on how she did.
Jukebox Carrie is likely one of the best American Idol judges ever!#AmericanIdol #JukeboxCarrie #CarrieUnderwood pic.twitter.com/CX0MAqKMLc
— Occam Was Proper (@OccamWasRight) March 10, 2025
@OccamWasRight
Me now that @carrieunderwood will get to grace our screens EVERY WEEK 😭🥹 #AmericanIdol pic.twitter.com/kEGNkg52Gk
— creech (not parody) (@creecher28) March 10, 2025
@creecher28
Holy crap. All of the sudden I like @carrieunderwood much more. Rock goddess #americanidol
— Johnny Rocket (@KingRocket1) March 10, 2025
@KingRocket1
Jukebox Carrie Underwood is method higher than Katy Perry sorry not sorry. #AmericanIdol #Idol
— Lizzy MacDonald (@Lizzard899) March 10, 2025
@Lizzard899
Carrie Underwood rocked it as an American Idol choose tonight! Liked her vitality and perception she brings to the present. Can’t wait to see extra of her on Idol this season! #AmericanIdol #CarrieUnderwood
— Meg⚡️💜 (@MeganMae012) March 10, 2025
@MeganMae012
Carrie Underwood is the UPGRADE #AmericanIdol Wanted. Again to the Basic Present. Nice Job 👏🏻 pic.twitter.com/AdsXQuJJkX
— B̲eth ЌΔ𝓨 🔥 (@PoisonDeathShot) March 10, 2025
@PoisonDeathShot
The present is MUCH higher with Carrie. Significantly better chemistry between the judges.
— DeeLorUs (@HeckSociety) March 10, 2025
@HeckSociety
After I completed watching the BB video games I began watching the primary present of the #AmericanIdol season. Carrie is killing it! She is a superb addition to this season. Her matches and her humorousness and musical variety make for a enjoyable present! Appears like a fantastic season forward.
— Jamie Heisler (@softbaljunkie46) March 10, 2025
@softbaljunkie46
…Carrie simply sang Korn with a contestant on American idol—
..I informed yall for YEARS that she is the American princess-/ actually Korn. She is a rustic/gospel singer. KORN! what’s subsequent? Dashboard?! @carrieunderwood
😀😻❤️loveeeee— brendadevine (@BrendaDevine) March 10, 2025
@BrendaDevine
I had no concept Carrie Underwood was such a lyrics wizard. She killed it on American Idol tonight!
— Cindy LaMar (@CindyLaMar) March 10, 2025
@CindyLaMar
@carrieunderwood vibing to Korn was not on my 2025 bingo card, however I preferred it #AmericanIdol
— Tom Murphy (@murphy1849) March 10, 2025
@murphy1849
Superb @carrieunderwood know the phrases to each music whether or not it’s nation heavy steel or Pop. Welcome again @AmericanIdol
— Connie Carberg (@ConnieScouts) March 10, 2025
@ConnieScouts
Carrie is such a refreshing change from Perry. Carrie could be very genuine. Love her.
— Wanda Nelson (@wanda_nels78125) March 10, 2025
@wanda_nels78125
New episodes of American Idol air Sundays at 8 p.m. ET on ABC.